Miguel de Unamuno on Guilt and Conscience
Tragic Sense of Life, trans. J.E. Crawford Flitch (Dover: 1954), orig. 1921, p. 291.
The fact that society is guilty aggravates the guilt of each one, and
he is most guilty who most is sensible of the guilt. Christ, the
innocent, since he best knew the intensity of guilt, was in a certain
sense the most guilty. In him the culpability, together with the
divinity, of humanity arrived at the consciousness of itself. Many are
wont to be amused when they read how, because of the most trifling
faults, faults at which a man of the world would merely smile, the
greatest saints counted themselves the greatest sinners. But the
intensity of the fault is not measured by the external act, but by the
consciousness of it, and an act for which the conscience of one man
suffers acutely makes scarcely any impression on the conscience of
another. And in a saint, conscience may be developed so fully and to
such a degree of sensitiveness that the slightest sin may cause him
more remorse than his crime causes the greatest criminal. And sin rests
upon our consciousness of it, it is in him who judges and in so far as
he judges. When a man commits a vicious act believing in good faith that
he is doing a virtuous action, we cannot hold him morally guilty, while
on the other hand that man is guilty who commits an act which he
believes to be wrong, even though in itself the act is indifferent or
perhaps beneficent. The act passes away, the intention remans, and the
evil of the act is that it corrupts the intention, that in knowingly
doing wrong a man is predisposed to go on doing it, that it blurs the conscience. And doing evil is not the same being evil. Evil blurs the
conscience, and not only the moral conscience, but the general,
psychical consciousness. And everything that exalts and expands
conscious is good, while that which depresses and diminishes it is evil.
Filed in...

Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.
Lest they devolve into the infantile comments on display at YouTube and elsewhere, comments require registration and are moderated, not for point of view but for quality. » Register or » Login